What is more important this summer: re-signing Chauncey or re-signing Amir?

[Glenn]

Discuss.

[Fool]

I chose Amir. We aren't winning anything next year anyway.

[Hermy]

Amir may be the least talented player on our roster, and worse at basketball than Dupree. I'll go C-bill.

[b-diddy]

because im ready for a changing of the guard, i chose amir. i dont have as high a hopes as some (higher than hermy), but i really have come to the conclusion i dont want c-bill back. i dont think i can take anymore of the same. get me a waterbug that will have us flying up and down the court and scoring 115 a game. no more going to work.

[Glenn]

I love how Hermy is always one of the first ones in with how he'd vote, and then he never does. I think that might be a schtick?

Anyways, I'm torn on this one and have been thinking about it a lot, which is why I posted it. I'll give it some more thought tonight while I pretend to listen about the wife's day at work.

[Zekyl]

.....while I pretend to listen about the wife's day at work.

I've always wondered if there was a way to make that time productive.

[Uncle Mxy]

Chauncey. Even if we don't want to keep Chauncey, his worth in S+T makes it a must, especially after the Big Ben debacle. Amir is someone where we hold all the cards, unlike Chauncey.

[Hermy]

I love how Hermy is always one of the first ones in with how he'd vote, and then he never does. I think that might be a schtick?

Anyways, I'm torn on this one and have been thinking about it a lot, which is why I posted it. I'll give it some more thought tonight while I pretend to listen about the wife's day at work.

LOL! I don't think I've ever actually voted in a poll, we don't use them at WRH. Still quick with the opinion.

And I don't think that is what Amir is, I just know it may be for all the general public knows. No non-Piston personell is on the record anywhere I'm aware of saying a good thing about him. Just "a scout" or "opposing GMs". I guess Chad Ford blew a load on him, but meh.

[Tahoe]

It's more important to sign Billups but if a s&t happened, it wouldn't bother me. Its more important to have Amir on the squad next year. I think we're in for a 2 to 3 year swoon.

Its amazing that we prolly have the most talented roster in the East and a lot of us wouldn't be calling the suicide hot line if we broke this team up.

[BIG BEN'S FRO]

Billups would net us a better player than in a S&T. That team also might trade a pick to us that we could parlay with our other two to move up and get another impact player. That all said, I say keep both.