Amar'e or Bosh?

[Glenn]

Since all we have left is fantasy, who would you prefer?

[Glenn]

I case anyone cares...

Amar'e Career Stats
Age: 26
Points: 21.0
Rebounds: 9.0
Assists: 1.4
Blocks: 1.5
TOs: 2.6
FG: .540
FT: .755
3FG: .192
Games: 432
Mins: 34:12
PF: 3.4

Bosh Career Stats
Age: 25 (on 3/24/09)
Points: 19.4
Rebounds: 9.0
Assists: 2.1
Blocks: 1.2
TOs: 2.2
FG: .488
FT: .793
3FG: .307
Hair: Horrible
Games: 413
Mins: 37:06
PF: 2.7

[Joe Asberry]

Bosh any day of the week and twice on sundays

[Glenn]

They're pretty even, IMO, but I'll side with Bosh on account of the microfracture.

[Glenn]

Amar'e
6'10"
249 lbs.

Bosh
6'10"
230 lbs.

[Fool]

Hair: Horrible

Not even close.

[Timone]

I'll side with Bosh, but not because Gl'enn did. I'm my own man.

[Glenn]

Anybody know if either of these two drink G2?

That could sway me.

[umichjenks]

Bosh any day of the week for the following reasons:

1. Bosh didn't have major knee surgery.
2. Bosh isn't as much of a whiner as Stoudemire. He seems like a Tayshaun type player but with more passion.
3. Better defender
4. Bosh's offensive game is more adapted to not having a superstar pg. What I mean is that Bosh can create for himself more than Stoudemire can.
5. Bosh is athletic but has a more developed game both on offense and defense. Whereas Stoudemire relies more heavily on his athleticism.

I know that Stoudemire's offensive game is growing and he is starting to nail his jumper, but I like Bosh better.

[Black Dynamite]

They are pretty even. Also as much as people rag on Stoudy he's probably a better defender in the post that Bosh imo.

I'd say Stoudy(not 100 percent sure i'd take him over bosh healthy, but at the moment yea), but you can't go wrong with either if they are healthy. IMO Stoudemire is a smarter player, settles for the jump shot alot less often(my one gripe about Bosh), can run the floor and score in the half court, has more experience.

Now because of Stoudy's injury history, Bosh pulls out the edge overall.