Jethro34
03-01-2006, 10:16 AM
A post by Filly in another thread inspired me here. I know a lot of people have an opinion on this so it should make for a decent thread.
With the way conferences have been established as having more teams and trying to build up supr conferences, I think the Big Ten needs to makes a move to compete.
Add a 12th team and have 2 divisions. There are a lot of other details, but I think it would be a big move.
So who would be the 12th team?
Notre Dame is an obvious candidate and would be a great fit since, in football, they already play UM, MSU and Purdue almost every year. It makes a ton of regional sense. I don't think they would ever do it strictly because of money. I wish the NCAA would force major schools to align with a conference to be recognized for postseason eligibility.
Pittsburgh is another possibility. They are a strong school in football and basketball which is attractive, and with Penn State in the conference it makes regional sense.
Louisville is another school I liked as an option before they switched to the Big East. I still like them, but they're a bit far south for the conference and I don't think they would switch conferences again so soon.
Iowa State is a fit for a few reasons, but the Big 12 wouldn't be an easy Conference to target. Perhaps we could take Iowa State and the Big 12 could take Memphis to fill their spot. Actually, Memphis is a better fit in the SEC. I think a complicated and unlikely, but logical move would be for the SEC to take Memphis and give up Arkansas. Arkansas would go to the Big 12, and Iowa State would go to the Big Ten.
Marshall is another interesting prospect. They've had a bit of football success in the past, but they're about as good as Northwestern in basketball. Not sure they would hang with the Big Ten very well.
Since I mentioned Marshall, I suppose West Virginia would be a possibility. They're currently quite strong in both sports. Maybe Marshall in the Big East would be a good replacement if we were to take West Virginia.
We can argue that the Big Ten is a top conference, but I think unless all conferences have the same number of teams, that's a difficult argument to make.
I think all BCS conferences should have 12 teams - no more, no less.
With the way conferences have been established as having more teams and trying to build up supr conferences, I think the Big Ten needs to makes a move to compete.
Add a 12th team and have 2 divisions. There are a lot of other details, but I think it would be a big move.
So who would be the 12th team?
Notre Dame is an obvious candidate and would be a great fit since, in football, they already play UM, MSU and Purdue almost every year. It makes a ton of regional sense. I don't think they would ever do it strictly because of money. I wish the NCAA would force major schools to align with a conference to be recognized for postseason eligibility.
Pittsburgh is another possibility. They are a strong school in football and basketball which is attractive, and with Penn State in the conference it makes regional sense.
Louisville is another school I liked as an option before they switched to the Big East. I still like them, but they're a bit far south for the conference and I don't think they would switch conferences again so soon.
Iowa State is a fit for a few reasons, but the Big 12 wouldn't be an easy Conference to target. Perhaps we could take Iowa State and the Big 12 could take Memphis to fill their spot. Actually, Memphis is a better fit in the SEC. I think a complicated and unlikely, but logical move would be for the SEC to take Memphis and give up Arkansas. Arkansas would go to the Big 12, and Iowa State would go to the Big Ten.
Marshall is another interesting prospect. They've had a bit of football success in the past, but they're about as good as Northwestern in basketball. Not sure they would hang with the Big Ten very well.
Since I mentioned Marshall, I suppose West Virginia would be a possibility. They're currently quite strong in both sports. Maybe Marshall in the Big East would be a good replacement if we were to take West Virginia.
We can argue that the Big Ten is a top conference, but I think unless all conferences have the same number of teams, that's a difficult argument to make.
I think all BCS conferences should have 12 teams - no more, no less.
